Top Eight Josh Allen Rookie Card Picks

Josh Allen's rookie cards have recently garnered major attention, making headlines after being auctioned for more than $300,000. And it's no surprise considering Allen's remarkable on-field performance and the Buffalo Bills’s growing fanbase.

Like any sports card investment, Josh Allen cards can make or break your portfolio, so it pays to read up on their history, graded supply, price range, brand, and other important factors. Ultimately, sports card collecting is exciting, and investing in Allen's cards is sure to be a wild rollercoaster ride.

Josh Patrick Allen is surely making a mark in the NFL. The 26-year-old Californian has been putting up stellar numbers each year.

After leading the Bills to a 10-win season and their second playoff appearance in 20 years, Josh went on to make history by taking them to their first AFC Championship game in 27 years.

On the field, he has the speed of a running back and the accuracy of a pro-level quarterback. Off the field, he holds endorsements from big brands like New Era, Nike, Microsoft, and Hyundai.

Josh Allen also earned his Bachelor's degree in Social Science from the University of Wyoming. He has most definitely taken the Bills to unseen heights, and all indications point to his performance only getting better.

With all of his talent, hard work, and success, it's no wonder why he's a two-time Pro Bowl selection and was recognized as a Second-team All-Pro in 2020. We can't wait to see what the future holds for this star quarterback.

Josh Allen rookie cards have been making big waves in the sports memorabilia world. In 2020, one of his cards fetched $264,000, and that's not even the highest price his cards have ever sold for—the most expensive one sold to date cost $312,000.

1. 2018 Panini National Treasures Rookie Colossal Material Signatures Josh Allen #RCSJA

• Price Range: $575 to $1,110
• Highest Sale Price: $1,500 (PSA 9)
• PSA 10 Supply: 5
• Brand: Panini

Collectors must feel like they hit the jackpot with the 2018 Panini National Treasures Rookie Colossal Material Signatures Josh Allen #RCSJA. That's because this highly sought-after card is so grand and exclusive, with its unique design, massive jersey patch, and Allen’s signature all in one package.

Seasoned collectors will be eager to get their hands on this scarce and sought-after card. PSA has even given its stamp of approval, setting the value of this treasure at $500,000 in mint condition.

2. 2018 Panini Donruss Josh Allen #304

• Price Range: $43 to $290
• Highest Sale Price: $330
• PSA 10 Supply: 7028
• Brand: Panini

Nobody puts Josh Allen in the corner. Add him to your collection with the 2018 Panini Donruss #304, an action-packed card that won't break the bank. With a price range of $43 to $290 and a PSA 10 supply of 7,028, you won't need to mortgage the house to add this Josh Allen card to your collection.

While it's widely available, the Panini Donruss Josh Allen #304 still commands a decent price, valued at around $20 to $30 for ungraded cards. So don't be scared of wild quarterback scrambles—getting your hands on Josh Allen won't be a scrimmage.

3. 2018 Panini Immaculate Collection Premium Patch Rookie Autograph Josh Allen #PRJA 

• Price Range: $1,420 to $17,400
• Highest Sale Price: $17,400
• PSA 10 Supply: 5
• Type: Panini

This is not your average sports card. It features a premium patch and Josh Allen's autograph, making it a rare and valuable find for collectors. The card has been sold on various marketplaces like eBay for prices ranging from $1,420 to $17,400.

PSA 10s of this card are in low supply—17 to be exact—making them super exclusive. The design of this card is simply stunning. And the premium patch and autograph make for a visually striking piece that will stand out in any collection. Considering their limited supply, it'll be like owning a piece of football history.

4. 2018 Panini Prizm Josh Allen Silver Prizm #205 

• Price Range: $875 to $10,105
• Highest Sale Price: $15,500
• PSA 10 Supply: 26
• Brand: Panini

Collectors everywhere are clamoring to get their hands on the elusive 2018 Panini Prizm Josh Allen Silver Prizm #205. It's a highly coveted rookie card due to its sleek design and limited availability, with a PSA 10 supply of only 26.

For those lucky enough to grab one in pristine condition, prices have been known to reach highs $15,500. But if you don't have that kind of money lying around, fear not—you can still get one for prices ranging from a bargain-friendly $875 to an eye-popping $10,000.

5. 2018 Panini Donruss Optic Josh Allen #154

• Price Range: $75 to $375
• Highest Sale Price: $1,469
• PSA 10 Supply: 1759
• Brand: Panini

Josh Allen's 2018 Panini Donruss Optic Card # 154 is the holy grail of NFL rookie cards—so rare that you can expect to pay between $75 to $375. There are only 1,759 graded a cool PSA 10.

Basically, if you're an Allen fan, then you better get to it, because this card is really something special. Not only is it colorful and detailed, but when it's displayed in its plastic sleeve, it'll instantly up the wow factor of your collection.

6. 2018 Panini Prestige Josh Allen #234

• Price Range: $12 to $120
• Highest Sale Price: $120
• PSA 10 Supply: 41
• Brand: Panini

It's no surprise that Josh Allen's rookie cards are all the rage, especially the 2018 Panini Prestige card #234—with such a cool blue and red backdrop, his Buffalo Bills uniform looks absolutely dynamite.

Plus, PSA 10 versions of this card have been selling for anywhere from $12.50  to $120—sounds like a real bargain for football fans looking to class up their collection.

7. 2018 Panini Donruss The Rookies Josh Allen #R4

• Price Range: $41 to $202
• Highest Sale Price: $400
• PSA 10 Supply: 29
• Brand: Panini

The 2018 Panini Donruss The Rookies Josh Allen #R4 card may not be as flashy as some of Allen's other rookie cards, but it can still be a valuable addition to any collection.

With a price range of $41 to $202, this card won't empty your wallet like some of the more expensive ones out there. Of course, if you're feeling really spendy, you could always splurge to beat the highest recorded sale of $400.

This card features Josh Allen in his Buffalo Bills uniform holding a football, and the PSA 10 supply of this card is only 29, so it's a rare find even without the on-card signature.

8. 2018 Panini National Treasures Jersey Autograph #163 

• Price Range: $10,000 to $104,400
• Highest Sale Price: $312,000
• PSA 10 Supply: 13
• Brand: Panini

Josh Allen's National Treasures Rookie Patch Autographs card is the cream of the crop of Allen auto cards. This stunning item sports an on-card autograph with bold blue ink.

This grail of a rookie card even has a manufacturer's warranty of authenticity, plus a multicolored patch component that’s just the icing on the cake. With just thirteen PSA 10s and one of them selling for a ridiculous $312,000, it's no surprise that this rare rookie card is worth shelling out for.

Investing in Josh Allen rookie cards is hotter than a buffalo wing in July. In 2022 alone, the value of these cards has skyrocketed, with some experiencing a surge of over 100%. Some of his most valuable cards include the 2018 Panini Prizm Silver, 2018 Panini Contenders Optic, and 2018 Panini National Treasures.

But don't worry, even budget collectors can cash in on the hype, with the 2018 Panini Donruss Optic being a solid card to collect. And, with a record-breaking sale of $312,000, it's clear that Josh Allen's performance on the field is directly correlated to the value of his rookie cards.

So whether you're a fan of the Buffalo Bills quarterback or simply looking for a potentially profitable investment, Josh Allen rookie cards are a touchdown-worthy addition to any sports card portfolio.