Best Jerry Rice Rookie Cards to Score in Your Collection
Best Jerry Rice Rookie Cards to Score in Your Collection

Best Jerry Rice Rookie Cards to Score in Your Collection

Jerry Rice's rookie cards, like the 1986 Topps #161, are prized among collectors for their rarity, significant history, and investment potential, as he's considered the most excellent NFL wide receiver.

Sports Cards

Sports Cards



Long Term Growth

Long Term Growth

Jerry Rice's extraordinary wide receiver skills have made a touchdown in the hearts of NFL fans. His legendary career, predominantly with the San Francisco 49ers, elevated him to iconic status and catapulted his memorabilia into the league of highly coveted collectibles.

With a population of only 61 cards, #161 is a scarce and, arguably, the most coveted Jerry Rice rookie card…fetching a peak value of $125,655 at an eBay auction in July 2021.

When investing in this football gem, two essential aspects to keep in mind are the condition and the grading of the card. Many of Rice's rookie cards might hover around the $100 mark. However, mint-condition cards can tackle even higher valuations head-on.

Undoubtedly, the Pro Football Hall of Fame-worthy 1986 Topps #161 rookie card continues to be a force to reckon with in the sports memorabilia sphere. It captures the hearts and wallets of passionate collectors and football connoisseurs alike.

Who is Jerry Rice?

Jerry Rice is celebrated as one of the best wide receivers in NFL history and made a lasting impact from the moment he joined the San Francisco 49ers after being drafted in the first round of the 1985 draft. 

Showcasing incredible speed, exceptional hands, and precise route-running, Rice's repertoire of skills has set numerous records and extraordinary milestones that have cemented his place in football history.

From his rookie year, Rice demonstrated unparalleled abilities, averaging an impressive 18.9 yards per catch. However, it was in 1986 that he began his legendary streak, leading the league in receiving yards and touchdown catches. 

As a testament to his consistency, Rice achieved more than 1,000 receiving yards for 11 consecutive seasons, notching double-digit touchdown catches in nine seasons.

Jerry Rice's influence extends beyond regular-season play. He set an astonishing single-season record of 22 touchdown receptions in 1987, and his career totals of 1,549 receptions, 22,895 receiving yards, and 208 total touchdowns are still unmatched today.

Rice's prowess shone brightly in the playoffs and Super Bowls, as he participated in eight conference championships and four Super Bowls, contributing significantly to the 49ers' three Super Bowl victories and securing a Super Bowl MVP title.

The consistency and excellence Jerry Rice displayed throughout his career earned him numerous accolades, including 11 consecutive seasons as a first-team All-Pro and 13 Pro Bowl selections. 

Rice's inclusion on the NFL's All-Decade Teams for the 1980s and 1990s, as well as the NFL's 75th Anniversary Team, are all evidence of his immense impact on American football.

Jerry Rice's unrivaled career statistics, jaw-dropping performances in crucial games, and incredible longevity have forever etched his name as the most prolific wide receiver in NFL history and one of the most exceptional players to grace the football field.

Most valuable Jerry Rice card list

Jerry Rice's cards should be on your radar if you're hunting for some rare and valuable cards. With few cards available, Jerry Rice's cards are considered rare and highly coveted. The 1986 Topps Football #161 card, in particular, is a hot commodity due to its rarity, which adds to its value.

Other Jerry Rice cards, like the 1986 McDonald's Jerry Rice 49ers #80, have also proven profitable investments. Investing in Jerry Rice's cards could be a smart way to diversify your portfolio. After all, hard-to-find cards like these are always in demand, and their values have consistently risen.

1. 1986 Topps Jerry Rice Rookie Card #161

  • Price Range: $17 to $82,100
  • Highest Sale Price: $125,655
  • PSA 10 Supply: 61 
  • Brand: Topps

The 1986 Topps Football #161 card is the ultimate prize for Jerry Rice collectors. Its green borders are prone to chipping, causing wear and tear, and centering issues often plague the card. Nevertheless, collectors and investors recognize the card's value, with Joe Orlando naming it one of the top 200 sportscards ever.

As a rare and unique sports collectible, the 1986 Jerry Rice card is worth pursuing for those who appreciate the advantages of diversifying their portfolios with alternative assets.

With a gem mint population of only 61 cards, #161 is a scarce and, arguably, the most coveted Jerry Rice rookie card. PSA reports that this card has been consistently positive in its performance, fetching a peak value of $125,655 at an eBay auction in July 2021.

Though the price has experienced a slight dip, another card sold for $75,000 at Robert Edward Auctions in August 2022—proving the card has mostly sustained its market value.

PSA 9 graded copies of this early Jerry Rice card are also valuable, fetching as much as $2,625 and as low as $103—which is still decent. From 2020 till mid-2021, near-mint cards experienced the best performance, with a gradual price increase before surges in mid-2021. However, prices have since steadied, with some occasional dips.

Much lower grades of this card still fetch handsome amounts. The lowest-priced PSA mint or near mint card sold for $166 on eBay, and the highest changed hands for $2,895. A more recent sale in March 2023 brought in $484, which is still quite significant. Non-graded cards have also proven lucrative, with significantly improved market performance compared to previous years.

Saturated supply from 2005 to 2021 resulted in stagnated prices for the SGC 7 graded copies of this card. However, the demand spiked from late 2021 to 2022, pushing prices to $430 due to its rarity.

Investors will want to take advantage of the 1986 Topps Jerry Rice #161. While the card’s prices have seen fluctuations in performance, it still holds significant value and can be a great addition to your collection.

2. 1986 McDonald's 49ers Jerry Rice (Orange) #80

  • Price Range: $41 to $4,000
  • Highest Sale Price: $3,999
  • PSA 10 Supply: 
  • Brand: McDonald's

The 1986 McDonald's Jerry Rice (Orange) #80 card is super scarce, with only 73 PSA-graded copies.

Jerry Rice's rookie card first released in 1986 as part of McDonald's 49ers All-Star collection, a promotional effort aimed at cashing in on football card mania. 

This set featured some of the NFL's best players, including Rice, and each team's cards were available in restaurants surrounding the club’s home turf. The All-Star issue included 30 nationwide cards and was available outside established NFL markets.

Each team had 24 different cards, with the San Francisco 49ers card set released in the Bay Area. The cards themselves were unnumbered and, therefore, usually listed by the player's uniform number, which, in Rice's case, was #80. 

The Jerry Rice card was distributed in different colors depending on the week, including black, blue, green, and orange. The orange version of the card is the most sought-after due to its rarity.

As of November 2022, the black-tab version of the Jerry Rice rookie card is the most common, with a PSA population report recording around 89 copies, followed by the blue and green tab cards. The orange tab card is the rarest, with only eight copies on record. Getting a pristine condition Jerry Rice rookie card is quite a challenge, especially with only five PSA 10 examples existing.

Despite the scarcity of the 1986 McDonald's Jerry Rice (Orange) #80 card, it has been fetching impressive returns even during periods of market uncertainty. The card has always stayed below its baseline value, which gives the asset excellent potential as part of a diversified portfolio.

It's worth noting that nothing is certain with investments—the overall performance of this card can fluctuate, just like any other alternative asset. Investors should be wise when setting out to acquire this prized sports memorabilia by monitoring supply and demand trends and staying informed of collector insights, current prices, and market forecasts.

Are Jerry Rice Rookie cards a good investment?

Now, you must be wondering—are these glorious Jerry Rice rookie cards worth dipping your toes into the football cards market? Let's break it down.

Rice's 1986 Topps rookie card is hailed as a collectible gem. As arguably the finest wide receiver in football history, Rice's legendary status has turned his official rookie card into a highly sought-after prize among collectors. In turn, the card's scarcity further skyrockets its value.

But remember, it's not just about the legendary status and Rice's prowess on the field—it's also about Rice's enormous fanbase, the San Francisco 49ers' enduring popularity, and the rich history associated with his memorabilia that keep the market demand for these cards high.

Grading plays a vital role in determining the value of a card, so before investing, examine the card's centering meticulously. Also, watch fellow football legends like Steve Young and Joe Montana, as their cards are equally popular in the collectible market.

For budding financial whizzes, monitoring price trends with cards like the gem mint version of Jerry Rice's McDonald's All-Stars and new releases from reputable brands like Upper Deck can make all the difference in your investing success over time.

The bottom line: it's crucial to stay prepared and evaluate your options before investing in cards like Rice's 1986 Topps rookie card. Collaborating with reputable partners like the eBay Partner Network can ensure a rock-solid investment strategy that turns your passion for collectibles into a flourishing financial venture. 

And that, folks, is what we call a touchdown in the alternative investing world.