Top 8 Patrick Mahomes Rookie Cards To Invest In 2023
Top 8 Patrick Mahomes Rookie Cards To Invest In 2023

Top 8 Patrick Mahomes Rookie Cards To Invest In 2023

Stay ahead of the curve with Patrick Mahomes rookie cards. Learn about the eight most valuable Mahomes cards and why they could be worthy of your collection.

Sports Cards

Sports Cards



Long Term Growth

Long Term Growth

Ready to take your sport card investments to the next level? Look no further than Patrick Mahomes cards. One of his cards reportedly sold for $4.3 million—and why would you stop at just one card when you could own the entire collection?

Chiefs fans and NFL followers are vying for Patrick Mahomes rookie cards like they’re the last bag of Doritos at a Super Bowl party. After all, Mahomes is one of the most electrifying players to hit the field in ages, and his rookie cards are likely to be the most coveted among football card collectors.

According to eBay, the price of one Mahomes rookie card rose by almost 607% in just three years, from $140 to around $970—a trend that’s likely to continue.

Not only is Mahomes an incredible athlete, but his journey from the youth football fields of Texas to the NFL is Hollywood-level stuff (watch out Sandra Bullock). With such an amazing record, it's no surprise that Patrick Mahomes rookie cards are some of the most sought-after NFL memorabilia.

From Prizms to auto patch to the beloved Laundry Tag NFL Shield—a must-have for every die-hard Chiefs fan—cop a Patrick Mahomes rookie card while they last. Investing in these cards could be the sports card jackpot. So why not take a chance and get in on a piece of this football legend?

Who is Patrick Mahomes?

Football phenom Patrick Lavon Mahomes is something of a superhero on the field. Hailing from Tyler, Texas, the 28-year-old quarterback of the Kansas City Chiefs grew up playing both football and baseball. After graduating high school, Mahomes accepted an athletic scholarship to Texas Tech University where his dual talents earned him multiple awards.

Following his three-year stint at Texas Tech, Mahomes embarked on his professional career. Since being the tenth overall draft pick in 2017 by KC, Mahomes has enthralled fans with his skills. He’s been awarded two NFL MVPs, two Super Bowl wins, five Pro Bowl selections, and has become the fastest to reach 20,000 career passing yards—talk about rapid-fire stats.

But Patrick Mahomes’s contributions aren’t confined to the field. He set up the 15 And The Mahomies Foundation in 2015, which is dedicated to the welfare of kids in underprivileged communities.

On top of that, he’s been recognized by the NFL Network, ESPN, and Sports Illustrated as one of the greatest football players of all time. Most recently, his ten-year $503 million contract extension was the third largest in sports history—it pays to be a superhero.

When he’s not crushing it on the football field or fighting for the greater good, Mahomes can be found at home with his family. Patrick Mahomes wife and high school sweetheart Brittany Matthews parents two kids alongside the Chiefs quarterback.

The seemingly unbeatable Pat Mahomes is, without a doubt, a football champion whose reputation will only grow in the coming years. That’s why practically everyone in the sports card hobby has their eyes on his rookie cards.

Most valuable Patrick Mahomes rookie cards to invest in

If you're looking to pick up Patrick Mahomes rookie cards and add some spunk to your collection, there's no shortage of options. The Panini National Treasures Rookie Patch Auto is a worthy pick. Or, take a risk and go for the Panini Select '17 NFL Draft XRC Patrick Mahomes II Gold Prizm Redemption—a card that’ll shine in your collection.

Other picks worthy of attention include parallels like the Prizms Light Blue, Printing Plates Yellow, Prizms Blue Wave, and Prizms Gold Vinyl. The Gold Vinyl Prizm Rookie Patch Autographs, Silver Prizm RC Rookie, and the Panini Prizm Football Gold Rookie are all worthy picks.

And who knows? Perhaps one will turn out to be a good investment.

You can never go wrong with a die-cut, jersey number, and an on-card signature, so don't miss out on the Panini Select XRC '17 NFL Draft Redemption.

Put that extra wow factor in your card collection with these Patrick Mahomes cards. Here are the eight best Patrick Mahomes rookie cards to add to your collection.

1. 2017 Panini National Treasures Patrick Mahomes II Patch Auto #161 

  • Price Range: $18,500 to $235,000
  • Highest Sale Price: $399,750 in October 2021
  • PSA 10 Supply: 8
  • Type: Panini

The 2017 Panini National Treasure Rookie Patch auto. #161, changed hands for $399,750 in October 2021.

This 2017 Panini National Treasures Rookie Patch Auto (RPA) #161 Patrick Mahomes II Signed Patch Rookie Card is a gold mine, selling at the Goldin Elite October auction for a staggering $399,750.

This card is a must-have for die-hard Mahomes fans, and why not add some value to your admiration of one of the best quarterbacks in the NFL? A certified PSA gem mint is the highest possible grade for this card and is likely to hold its value for years to come.

With Pat Mahomes 2017 National Treasures Platinum card setting a record as the most expensive NFL card, investing in this one could be a smart move.

2. 2016 Panini Select '17 NFL Draft Xrc Prizm Redemption Gold #2

  • Price Range: $1,234 to $4,150
  • Highest Sale Price: $192,000 
  • PSA 10 Supply: 1
  • TypePanini Select

Patrick Mahomes Panini Select ‘17 NFL Draft Xrc Prizm Redemption which sold for $192,000 at an auction in December 2020.

It's a no-brainer to invest in the 2016 Panini Select '17 NFL Draft XRC Patrick Mahomes II Gold Prizm Redemption #2 card for several reasons. For one, Mahomes is an incredibly popular player and his rookie cards are precious gems.

It's even more special being part of the limited XRC redemption set. The card went on sale at a Heritage Auctions Fall Sports Collectibles Catalog Auction in Dallas in 2020, where it was sold for an outrageous $192,000. That's far more than what most people make in a year. It's certainly a great investment for any card collector.

3. 2017 Panini Immaculate Collection Rookie Premium Patch Autograph Patrick Mahomes II #PR-PM

  • Price Range: $4,000 to $96,000
  • Highest Sale Price: $96,000
  • PSA 8 Supply: 2
  • Type Panini Immaculate Collection

The Patrick Mahomes Panini Immaculate Collection Collection, RPP Auto. auctioned in November 2022 for $96,000.

Forget gold or stocks, a Patrick Mahomes autograph card from the 2017 Panini Immaculate Collection Rookie Premium Patch Autographs NFL Shield #PR-PM is the ultimate investment opportunity—worth 96,000 of your hard-earned dollars.

Who knows, you could be make bank off this priceless collectible if Patrick Mahomes suddenly decides to quit football and become a ukulele player. But let's be honest, that's highly unlikely.

4. 2016 Panini Select '17 NFL Draft XRC Prizm Redemption Patrick Mahomes II #2 (Tie-Dye)

  • Price Range: $18,988 to $62,730
  • Highest Sale Price: $62,730
  • PSA 10 Supply: 3
  • Type: Panini Select

2016 Patrick Mahomes Panini Select '17 NFL Draft XRC Tie-Dye Prizm Redemption sold in March for $62,370.

The 2016 Panini Select ‘17 NFL Draft XRC Tie-Dye Prizm Redemption #2 Patrick Mahomes II Rookie Card is the hottest ticket in town due to its rarity—only 3 of these exist.

The card fetched an astonishing $62,730 in 2021, proving it's worth more than a pretty penny. Even with the steep price tag, collectors everywhere are rolling up their sleeves, ready to snatch up this three-of-a-kind card for the ultimate bragging rights.

5. 2017 Panini Prizm Patrick Mahomes II #269 (Gold Prizm)

  • Price Range: $44,999 to $577,102
  • Highest Sale Price: $45,000
  • PSA 10 Supply: 3
  • Type: Panini Prizm

2017 Patrick Mahomes Panini Prizm Football Gold Rookie #269 fetched $45,000 in April 2020.

Are you feeling lucky? Then this 2017 Panini Prizm #269 Patrick Mahomes Gold Rookie card is the buy for you. Boasting a unique on-card autograph, this RC Auto Patch is the ultimate collector's item—the envy of anyone you show it to.

All the Light Blue, Blue Wave, and Gold Vinyl cards in the world won't compare. A PSA 10 version of this card is currently valued at $577,102 on eBay—so don't miss out on picking up this Patrick Mahomes Rookie card as soon as you can.

Plus, you’re sure to have peace of mind knowing that this golden ticket is in mint condition and its value is likely to increase over time. So don't be a turkey. Put your money where your mouth is and score this card before it disappears.

6. 2017 Panini Prizm Rookie Patch RC Autograph Prizm Patrick Mahomes II #PM (Gold)

  • Price Range: $19,200.00
  • Highest Sale Price: $19,200 
  • PSA 9 Supply: 2
  • TypePanini Prizm

Patrick Mahomes Panini Prizm Rookie Patch Autographs Gold Prizm sold for $19,200 in January 2022.

This card is a great investment—it's so rare, and its latest auction price, an astounding $19,200, was enough to make even a penny-pinching investment banker take notice.

The card's appeal is only growing with the success of 2023 Super Bowl Champs the Kansas City Chiefs and their star quarterback Patrick Mahomes. It's probably a good idea to buy two to three of these cards if only to make sure that you have some left over. Plus, it looks pretty neat on the wall, too.

7. 2017 Panini Prizm Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card #269 

  • Price Range: $650 to $7,300
  • Highest Sale Price: $20,100
  • PSA 10 Supply: 910
  • Type: Panini Prizm

Patrick Mahomes II Silver Prizm RC Rookie which sold for $20,100 in February 2021.

The 2017 Panini Prizm Patrick Mahomes II Silver Prizm RC #269 is a shining example of why the saying "money can't buy happiness" is a lie—because this card is pure joy.

This card—and even parallels like the Prizms Green Scope—has jumped in value recently and it's hard to find one in better condition than a PSA 10. Besides being an awesome collectible, Patrick Mahomes is quickly becoming a recognizable NFL player, making this card a must-have.

This card was previously listed on eBay where it sold for a staggering $20,100.

Talk about a major league investment. So, why invest in the 2017 Panini Prizm #269 Patrick Mahomes II Silver Prizm RC Rookie? Well, it's a fantastic way to add some long-term value to anyone's portfolio. But let's be honest, it's mainly because it's awesome as fuck.

8. 2016 Panini Select '17 Nfl Draft Xrc Prizm Redemption Patrick Mahomes II #2

  • Price Range: $1,234 to $4,150
  • Highest Sale Price: $18,500
  • PSA 10 Supply: 214
  • TypePanini Select

The 2016 Panini Select Patrick Mahomes II XRC #2 '17 NFL Draft Redemption sold for $5,350 at an October 2022 auction. 

The 2016 Panini Select Patrick Mahomes II XRC #2 '17 NFL Draft Redemption card is highly sought-after by collectors and investors worldwide and is an opportunity too good to fumble.

Not only is it one of just 15 to 30 cards, with Prizms like Light Blue, Gold Vinyl, Green Scope, and Purple Scope, but also a host of other features like a Bronze Star and Football Card, an on-card autograph, a season stat line, and bragging rights to boot.

Are Patrick Mahomes cards a good investment?

Patrick Mahomes rookie cards are worth going the extra distance to get. With talent and potential unmatched by any other NFL QB, investing in a Mahomes rookie card could be a smart move.

His iconic performance on the field has made him a household name for both the young and old, and his valuable rookie cards aren't likely to be getting any cheaper. If you want to reap the rewards of owning some sports card royalty, act fast before Mahomes cards disappear faster than a touchdown pass.

Patrick Mahomes is the GOAT—and that goes for sports card collecting, too. The NFL star's cards are rising in value faster than any young quarterback in history, even spurring the creation of a cereal in his honor.

A BGS 8.5 2017 National Treasures NFL Shield Mahomes Rookie Auto one-of-one card is currently the most expensive Mahomes rookie card ever sold, fetching $4.3 million in a private sale.

As a relatively young player, he still has tons of football left in him, meaning now's the time to get your hands on his cards. Who wouldn't want to profit off of their fandom?

Additionally, the popularity of the sport also plays a role here. The core sports card market, made up of baseball, basketball, and football cards, was worth an estimated $7.8 billion in 2021 and is expected to increase to $20.4 billion by 2030.

Since the NFL is the most popular professional sports league in the U.S., more people are flocking to NFL cards, which adds further value to Mahomes cards as an investment. Demand follows supply, after all.

All these factors indicate that Patrick Mahomes cards can be a good investment.

However, it’s essential to note that sports card investing is still a speculative market, so like all investments, there’s no guarantee of success. Sports card investors should research, do due diligence, and make sure their heart is in it for the right reason before buying football cards as a speculative asset.